Somehow in the terrible nightmare of the election aftermath, a post about “kid shaming” came across my facebook feed. I will not repost this article. It is clearly a spin off of “dog shaming” posts with photos of dogs oblivious to the signs their owners wrote, declaring their misdeeds. Like, “I like to eat out of the litter box.” The dog shaming posts are mildly funny, in my mind, because the dogs are oblivious. The dogs are not feeling shame, and that’s why it’s funny.
Kid-shaming is very different. Mixed in with general expressions of parent angst (“I pooped one minute after mommy changed my diaper!” next to a smiling baby), there are posts of real shame. Two little boys with a sign that says “we got toothpaste all over the bathroom.” A child walking through a public place, his head hanging, wearing a sign that says “I stole money from my mom’s friend.” A little boy looking miserable and holding a sign that says “I went outside by myself.” Apparently it is a trendy punishment to force children to stand in traffic holding a sign to say what they have done wrong – there are quite a few of those images.
This is not funny.
This is not the same thing as dogs smiling about licking their own butts.
This is not ok.
I want to raise my children to have no concept of shame, so that shame has no power over them – not to use shame as a tool to make them more obedient, or to laugh at their expense. I would never want my children, or any other child, to feel like this girl.
Even if you don’t agree with me that it is morally wrong to use shaming against children, it is also not an effective way to teach self-discipline. Instead all it does is create powerful emotions that neither the adult doing the shaming or the child being shamed can control.
In many children, their feelings are magnified well beyond the proportions of us adults, who have perspective of more years. Shame, in particular, is felt keenly by any human, and so its magnification can be exponential in children and teens. The sheer weight of these feelings can be too heavy, too unrelenting. A child or a teen doesn’t understand that these feelings will get easier and even end at some point.
Shaming also runs the risk of being far out of proportion with the behavior you’re trying to stop, and that’s because embarrassment is largely defined by the individual. It’s impossible to externally control it.
Children need to learn self-discipline. They learn this through the opportunity to make choices, good role models, clear boundaries, reasonable supervision (especially for two year olds! They’re sneaky!), and consistent engagement from the adults around them. Adults need more time to spend with their kids, and we all need help – no one person should have full responsibility for a child with no break. The answer is not to be “permissive,” and let your child get away with being an asshole, but to engage with them as human beings and give them opportunities to learn how to make good choices. Shaming a two year old for going outside without permission is not going to accomplish that.
